Saturday, October 07, 2006

Are We Fighting the Wrong War?


From remarks made by top NATO generals in Afghanistan, both Canadian and American, it seems there are two wars underway in that country, ours and the Taliban's. When our generals give us body counts and talk about decisive victories, they're talking about our war which they depict as a military war. That war is a dangerous distraction.

The war that matters is the Taliban's war and that's a political war. The Taliban isn't out to destroy our forces, they know they can't. They fight our weaknesses not our strengths. They retain the initiative, giving battle only when it suits them. Their war is aimed at discrediting the government, driving a wedge between the Karzai government and the Afghan people.

We declared victory in the recent battle of Panjwai. We won, militarily, because when it was all over the insurgents had left the field. That was our war. What we didn't do was to deny the Taliban a victory in their war, the political war. They stood and took everything we threw at them: small arms, artillery, rockets, attack helicopters, jet strike fighters. They showed the Afghan peasants they could take everything we had and still retire, on their own terms, in good order. They didn't kill many of our people but that wasn't important to their war. They won their war.

Of the two wars, theirs is the only one that really matters. This is their country, these are their people. We are aliens in that country. Our languages are foreign to them, we come from far-distant lands with foreign cultures, foreign religions and foreign lifestyles. Many Pashtun may not like it but the Taliban are the home team and they have the home team advantage. Even those who may not like the Taliban probably take some ethnic pride in watching the local boys best yet another foreign occupier in a long list of foreign occupiers.

If we were defending an honest, effectual government that the people supported, everything would be so much better. But the population is turning against Karzai and all the corruption and, when they do that, they're also turning against us. At this point reconstructing the Karzai government may be a lot more important than building new schools and roads. First, however, our political and military leaders must realize we need to fight the other guy's war, the one that matters.

5 comments:

  1. Hey Chuck, get some air! I'm not supporting the Taliban. I'd like to see them defeated but we have to fight their war. "Sad, pathetic insular"? Open your mind, take some time to learn about this miserable country and its problems. Or not. Your personal attacks just make you look foolish.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good observations and post. Unfortunately the situation is much more incredibly complex so it's going to take a long time for most conservative minds to grasp onto reality.
    Our good intentions notwithstanding there isn't a hope in hell of sorting the thing out.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Excellent post. The general populous of Afghanistan are extremist muslims and Do support the Taliban. By showing up and shooting the baddies, we are simply adding to the Myth of Martyr that they like to project. We are portraying our troops as freedom bringers but really we are viewed as oppressors and occupiers by the average fundy Afghani.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  5. And Chuck. You know what? You sound just like those annoying little Cuban Ex-Pats in Florida who claim that everyone in Cuba hates Castro, when in fact, that is quite the opposite. Vocal Minority, thats them and thats you, spreading your disinfo to forward your agenda.

    ReplyDelete