Showing posts with label political leadership. Show all posts
Showing posts with label political leadership. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 09, 2010

Playing For Time

If nothing else, the past ten years have painted a rich tableau of the seismic changes underway in our world. The depletion of non-renewable resources; the exhaustion of renewables; global warming and associated severe weather events; species extinctions and migration; deforestation; desertification; air, soil and water contamination; floods and droughts; the unstoppable migration of pests and diseases; nuclear proliferation and the spread of terrorism; regional arms races; climate migration and overpopulation; and the multi-directional onslaught of global freshwater stocks. Over the past decade how many of these have we fixed? How many have we solved? How many have worsened and how many have improved?

Now consider the next ten years. How many of these issues that confront, sometimes even threaten mankind, are we preparing to remedy? How many of them will we fix or solve by 2020? How many will worsen over the next decade and how many will improve?

And then the clincher. What will our world and our civilization look like with a further decade of erosion on these critical fronts? Will we become a less cohesive, more fractured civilization rent along regional lines staring angrily at each other over a widening chasm that divides the "haves" from the "have nots"? Will mankind's abilities, our strength atrophy as these threats grow ever more powerful? Does anyone seriously believe that mankind is going to be stronger ten years from now than it is today?

The fact is, we in the most advantaged, most affluent West are the key and yet we're still not willing to look beyond our blind faith in growth and prosperity to catch a glimpse of what lies just on the other side. Our leaders, those we've traditionally looked to for vision and guidance? Well they're not leaders, not really. They've long since learned it's far easier to manipulate an electorate with fear, anger and outright deception than to motivate them with vision and guidance.

So what they're doing is playing for time. Why do you think all these religious fanatics have arrived on the political scene today, these "end of times" nutjobs? They see the same world you do only in the context of Armageddon and "The Rapture" when their god sweeps them up into his arms. Their perverse zealotry sees these looming threats as harbingers of divinely better times just ahead and, coming from that perspective, who would want to change anything?

Then there are the weak and feckless secularists, people like Michael Ignatieff. Every now and then they might be able to screw up their courage and blurt out the words "global warming" before morphing into advocates for the Athabasca Tar Sands. Do you think this variety of sickly leadership is going to face up to any of these environmental threats and challenges? If you do, you're only fooling yourself.

No, sorry but these guys are just playing for time. Harper, cozy in his fundie cocoon, doesn't believe there's any need to act and Ignatieff can't muster the courage and vision to do any better.

I'd love to hear one of these ersatz leaders read the opening paragraph of this piece and then respond to the listed questions. These are existential challenges to our civilization, to mankind itself. Don't you think anyone claiming himself fit to lead our country should be able to acknowledge these problems and show us how we should be responding to them? I sure do.

At some point we're not going to be able to duck these problems. They'll overtake us or land unexpectedly on our doorstep, peaceably or otherwise. Are we preparing ourselves to deal with them when that day arrives? No, of course not. But it's not entirely our leaders' fault. It's ours too. We sit by and allow them to just bury their heads in the sand. That suits us too. We're all just playing for time.

Tuesday, May 04, 2010

Even Academics Ignore our 800 Pound Gorilla

Yesterday there was a fascinating exploration of the political and security issues arising out of China's ascent to global economic supremacy. Today there's an interesting discussion at the Huffington Post on how America will respond to its debt crisis. Reading these projections is eye-opening and thought-provoking but virtually all of them have the same fatal flaw - they totally ignore the mounting impacts of climate change and associated environmental threats. We're looking at problems in isolation of realities we cannot afford to overlook and it's backfiring on us.

Huffington refers to the era we're in as the "Age of Much Worse Than We Thought It Would Be." From Katrina to Wall Street, America's problems (and they're not alone) are starting to become almost uncontrollable or at least unmanageable:

...In practically every sector of our society, the old order is exhausted. But we seem incapable of making fundamental changes without the loaded gun of a full-blown crisis pointed at our heads. For example, the financial crisis -- and what it has exposed about the behavior of Wall Street -- has caused us to rethink the relationship between Wall Street and rest of our economy.

It's obvious the old way of doing things is no longer viable. But, absent the sense that everything is about to collapse, we are dragging our feet on deciding what will replace it.
And there are some other "unprecedented," "unique" -- and potentially catastrophic -- problems headed our way if we continue to accept the old order's lack of imagination about what is possible. I'm thinking, first and foremost, of our debt problem.


...America is like a patient in danger of suffering a massive heart attack. We may be able to postpone things with a bit of outpatient surgery, but we won't be able to avoid it without some serious lifestyle changes. The economic coronary isn't quite here yet, but it's on the way. And when it hits, it will, of course, be "unprecedented" and "unique." But not unforeseen -- let alone unforeseeable. Here are just a couple of the symptoms of big time trouble ahead:

By 2020, interest on the debt alone will reach $900 billion per year.
That same year, five segments of government spending -- Medicare, Medicaid, Social Security, net interest and defense spending -- will
account for an estimated 77 percent of all government expenditures. All other federal spending will have to come out of the remaining 23 percent.

...The needs of the past and the demands of the present exert a powerful pull on our attention while the future doesn't have many advocates -- it's always something we can get to later. And there was a time when we could get away with pushing our problems down the road, secure that our reserves would always bail us out. And there was a strong safety net to catch those who fell through the cracks. Well, those reserves are gone now and the safety net is frayed and full of holes.

...For a change, let's imagine a crisis that is worse than we think it will be, and take the necessary steps to avoid it. If we don't, we'll find ourselves facing another "unprecedented" disaster.

Huffington is dead right. The old order is over, we have to accept that. The 80's are gone - politically, economically, socially even militarily. By clinging to the past we undermine our ability to prepare for the future. We have to stop operating on a "best scenario" basis and stop falling back on some intangible trust that the future will take care of itself.

What she is saying is that there's an enormous leadership void today and I would argue nowhere more so than in Canada. Ours is a country led by people without vision, incapable of laying out a path for the future, ours, our children's and our grandchildren's. This is an unoccupied field just waiting for someone to answer the challenge. That "someone" should have been Michael Ignatieff but he's shown himself not up to it.

Friday, April 02, 2010

What It Takes to Lead

The most frustrating and scary aspect of climate change is the way our political leadership does backflips to avoid having to engage the issue. They act as though, if they don't mention it, the problem will go away - for them anyway.

We don't talk about global warming in Canada except perhaps to argue whether it's real or a hoax perpetrated by an international coven of dodgy scientists out for ...well for something. Our politicians, particularly the wily Harpo, realize that, so long as they can keep the debate at the stage of doubt, they can avoid having to do anything. To hedge their bets they can claim to want to synchronize Canada's efforts with America's, confident in the knowledge that special interests (Big Coal, Big Oil) have America's bought and paid for Congress well and truly stitched up. Washington is the best rearguard Ottawa's elected Tar Sanders could hope for.

The one thing that might undo Ottawa's efforts to bury the climate change issue is leadership. Michael Ignatieff, like Stephen Harper, is a committed Tar Sander so don't expect him to do the job he was annointed to perform - lead. Somebody else is going to have to be found and fairly quickly.

Leadership on global warming begins by getting the facts out before the public. The Brits did just that for their people. They told the British people that, "based on the greenhouse gas emissions in the atmosphere today - even without any additional emissions - powerful change is coming. Here is the 'best possible' scenario and you need to begin planning and preparing for at least that."

We know that emissions are going to continue, that they're poised to increase substantially. So what does the British policy really achieve? It actually achieves its purpose. It gets the public engaged in the issue. It shows them a real bottom line, even if it is vastly understated. The public understands that. Once you get information out to the public, once you get the public engaged, then - and only then - can you open the discussion on the touchy subjects - emissions cuts, adaptation and remediation.

Dion's folly is that he didn't come close to fulfilling the information and engagement process before unveiling his "Green Shift" proposal. You can't sell that sort of thing unless the public, properly informed, is ready for change. Dion failed and he really ought to have known better.

During the Frost interviews, Richard Nixon opined that the true measure of political leadership was the ability to get the public to support an otherwise unpopular but necessary initiative. Dion wasn't up to that task and Iggy and Harper don't even want to try.

What issue is more important than this one that threatens the continuation of our very civilization? Day care or corporate taxation? Budgets and deficits? Afghanistan or senate reform? Somehow nothing else comes close. That'd take something like global nuclear war but that doesn't seem likely, at least not right now. So why do Liberals tolerate a guy like Ignatieff and his supporters in caucus who so brazenly shirk their responsibility on global warming?

Don't blame me. I've written to them and I've tried to get the IgLibs to follow the British government's lead and actually use it against Harper. Convene parliamentary hearings. Get people like Hansen and Lovelock and their Canadian counterparts before a commons committee to speak plainly. Force Harper to take the gags off EnviroCan and get meaningful, reliable information out before the public. I guess the genius responsible for keeping the LPC at least four or five points behind the Cons in the polls knows better. They know that if they don't rock the boat they can stay safely behind where neither vision nor courage are mandated.

Which brings me to this helpful bit of prose:

"And we find that this struggle is more complex, more awkward, and more wide-ranging than we had thought possible... What involves us today is a struggle of far greater proportions yet with fewer handles for men and women to grasp. It is not the absence from the scene of a Pitt or a Churchill that causes men and women to wonder in what direction humanity is pointed, it is the nature of the adversary. More than eloquence and more than leadership is required to come to grips with monetary imbalances, nutritional deficiencies, and environmental pollution... Yet these struggles are the essence of life on this planet today. They are not struggles that can be confined to a law court or a battlefield or a House of Commons; they require institutions and regimes of immense dimensions and novel attributes; they call - in the final analysis - for worldwide cooperation, for they demand that we struggle not against other human beings but with other human beings. They demand a common cause of humanity."

- Pierre Trudeau, from a speech delivered at Mansion House on his being honoured with the freedom of the City of London. Taken from "Just Watch Me, the Life of Pierre Elliott Trudeau 1968-2000" by John English. There was a leader who wouldn't have balked in the face of global warming.