How did it all get so scary that it became painful even to write about it? How did it all go so wrong?
We're confronted by a bucketful of challenges today, some existential, the rest mere crises. But it seems we're surrounded by them. We've got the big one, global warming, the civilization ender. And then we've got all the associated environmental scourges - deforestation, desertification, species extinction and migration, pest and disease migration, the fisheries collapse, the freshwater crisis (the second biggie) and the food crisis, air/soil/water contamination, and that other biggie, overpopulation. Then we've got the non-environmental crises - the debt crisis, terrorism and other global security threats, nuclear proliferation and various regional arms races and the realignment of major powers and their spheres of influence.
I'm old enough, just barely, to remember the Cuban missile crisis. Where I was brought up, we looked across the river at Detroit. We all knew that the Soviets had Detroit in their nuclear crosshairs. We got air raid siren drills every Saturday at noon. We watched the Nike Hercules missiles pop out of the ground on their gantries, one by one, glistening white in the midday sun. So, when the Cuban missile showdown came, even kids like me were under no illusions what it would mean if the crisis got out of control.
I also remember that, while we thought we were at serious risk of annihilation, we had confidence that John Kennedy would find a way to keep that from happening. We had apprehension but we didn't live in utter terror. And we knew that when we got through this one, things would get better - and so they did.
Ah the good old days when all you had to fear was nuclear Armageddon. What I wouldn't give to feel that secure again. The thing is today I sure don't. I feel we're in far worse trouble than anything we faced in the 50's and 60's. And I feel we've arrived at this point when we're all saddled with huge leadership deficits. Obama has proven as useless as tits on a boar hog. We've got Harper and he's completely out of his depth on any of this stuff. The Euros don't seem to be doing much better and a deep rift is developing between the frugal northern states and their wastrel southern cousins. Can't imagine how that's going to turn out.
China and India are arriving at the party only to find we've wolverined the cabin. We gorged ourselves on everything we could possibly eat and then pissed on the rest. It's hard to blame them for being a bit angry. If we think we've got problems what lies in store for China and India is far worse.
Today there doesn't seem to be even one country with a leader capable of dealing with this cornucopia of challenges, all needing answers. Not one grasps that the solutions to these problems are inter-related. There are common threads that run through them all and it is in these that any solutions to be had will be found. These threads are all tied to one core reality - that we're trying to live beyond the limits of a very finite biosphere. Solving these troubles is going to require answers first and foremost configured to address that reality.
We're going to pay a horrible price if we don't see three forces at play in our crises - overpopulation, over-consumption and over-contamination. There are too many of us, we eat too much and we don't clean up after ourselves. Each of those prevents us from living in balance with our one and only source of life, our biosphere. It's the only one we've got. There aren't any others. If we can't live in balance with it, the biosphere will become uninhabitable and it's nearing the brink of that right now.
These are the realities we have to accept if we're to have any hope of getting out of this mess more or less intact. These realities have to be accepted as the guiding considerations on which solutions are to be devised. All things that cannot be made to conform to these guiding considerations prevent us from finding balance within our biosphere and must, therefore, be abandoned and replaced. We must do this because we have no other choice to save our civilization.
What that means, in part, is an end to the 18th century economics, 19th century industrialism and 20th century geopolitics that steered us straight into our perilous predicament. Those were all shaped in times of much different circumstances when mankind hadn't yet overpopulated the biosphere, when our consumption was still within our planet's means and when our contamination was not yet existential. It was a time when economic growth was the great elixir, a solution to our every social ill. Those days are gone and they're not coming back.
Although the wealthiest parts of the planet have not truly sensed it yet, we're running out of stuff. We have exceeded our biosphere's carrying capacity. The evidence of this is tangible. It is unquestionable in our collapsed global fisheries. It is visible from space in vast tracts of deforestation and desertification, the disappearance of polar ice and the retreat of glaciers on every continent.
The Global Footprint Network evaluates "nature's supply in the form of biocapacity, the amount of resources the planet generates, and compares that to human demand: the amount it takes to produce all the living resources we consume and absorb our carbon dioxide emissions." In 1976 mankind began exceeding our planet's biocapacity, falling into biocapacity deficit, eating our seedcorn. At the dawn of this century, World Overshoot Day fell in early October, leaving us with a three month overconsumption of natural resources. Last year that had advanced to August 21. This year it will be earlier still. It's a global conjuring act. We're fouling our atmosphere, emptying our oceans, felling our forests and overworking once productive farmland, turning it into useless desert in our furious efforts to satisfy unsustainable consumption - and every year it gets that much worse than the year before. Any guesses as to how this must end if we don't change course?
Overshoot itself demonstrates the fallacy of the self-regulating free market. Unregulated free market capitalism pays no heed to excess. It operates to maximize production and consumption and profits through constant growth. It ignores the vital distinction between needs and wants. It feeds off over-consumption, overpopulation and fuels over-contamination. Free market capitalism offends every guiding consideration we need to accept to get out of this predicament.
When growth becomes impossible, then traditional growth-based economics must yield to allocation-based policy where needs prevail over wants. People are willing to tolerate inequality and excess when growth is available to "lift all boats" but expect much more frugal and egalitarian outcomes when supply is allocation-based, that is to say rationed.
If we do not accept the principle of needs over wants we have no hope of regulating consumption back within our planet's renewable biological capacity. And if we reject that choice then someone, a great many someones will have to die. We either all eat small, measured portions from the same pie or the privileged get the pie and the remainder get none and die in any one of several resulting ways. It really is as simple as that. We have used clever conjuring acts, like the Green Revolution, to create the illusion of sufficiency but, in the process, used unsustainable quantities of groundwater for irrigation and ruinous amounts of fertilizer that exhaust the soil. Today in India, for example, the soil has become so degraded that crops now require twice as much fertilizer as was needed two decades ago. Pretending that the next grand solution is just around the corner is nihilistic denial.
We in the West, the earth's unrivaled consumers, will have to sacrifice most. In part that would mean living within our means as defined by our national borders. The GFN calculations show the United States currently consuming double its natural biocapacity. By eliminating needless waste and rolling back excess, the American people could still live sustainably in a genuinely comfortable standard of living.
While we in the West indulge in the sin of gluttony, much of the emerging nations and the Third World need to atone for their destructive overpopulation. Asia, south and east, comprise nearly half the world's population and their numbers are burgeoning with Africa now in pursuit. We're already at 7-billion in 2011 and that number is predicted to reach 9 to 10-billion by mid-century and possibly up to 15-billion by 2100. Those are civilization-destroying figures. In a finite world, numbers matter and numerical inequality through profligate procreation is as cardinal a sin as the gluttony of the West. These nations likewise need to live within the natural biocapacity of their national borders. Their biocapacity must set the limit of their population, consumption and waste.
For assets that do not fall within our national boundaries, essential assets such as the atmosphere and the oceans we have to treat them as "commons." No one owns them and, hence, everyone has an equal right to them. The atmosphere's remaining CO2 carrying capacity has to be apportioned out on a per capita basis. We in the industrialized West have no more right to the atmosphere than any other region, nation or individual. The same holds true for our oceans. We in the West have no natural right to claim the lion's share of our planet's fisheries. Unless we accept the principle of equality, these essential assets will be utterly ruined.
Does this mean that capitalism is dead? No, of course not. It means, however, that capitalism's more predatory instincts will have to be curbed and it will have to be brought into support of our guiding considerations. That may sound radical but there's nothing truly radical in necessity.
Can we do this? Yes, of course. We can because we must. Plan B is too horrible to comprehend. Will we do it? Not until we recognize the absolutely essential need for it, accept the guiding considerations and use them to shape our future, and then persuade, cajole and coerce our species to implement a new order, one that answers to needs, not wants. We have a great deal to do and a very limited amount of time in which to do it.
Thursday, August 11, 2011
When Privilege Becomes Indefensible
Lately there has been a spate of reports about the rich flocking to high end shops and indulging in the sort of luxuries reminiscent of the days before the Great Recession. Even as the working classes struggle to make ends meet and lines blur between the merely poor and the outright destitute, the richest of the rich seem oblivious and bent on flaunting their good fortune. Let them eat cake, indeed.
There are some now questioning whether the ongoing riots spreading through British cities are more than simple criminality and perhaps are harbingers of social upheaval, uprisings. Plenty of governments today wield the lash of austerity yet its sting is felt mainly by those least able to bear it, the most vulnerable - the homeless, the unemployed and the working poor. Many of these people realize that their government hasn't trimmed the sails for everyone. A privileged class exists that is, by good fortune, investment strategy and benevolent government, exempt from austerity measures, safely removed from all that.
Britain's Conservative prime minister David Cameron is waging an austerity war and it can be fairly said he's fighting it on the backs of the poorest and weakest. Yet, when the youth of this economically disenfranchised sector take to the streets to riot, Cameron dismisses it as nothing more than rank criminality. Two centuries ago the Brits knew how to deal with these types. They transported them to distant penal colonies, notably Australia. I'm sure Cameron must yearn for those good old days.
But what of the United States, where "rags'n riches" has achieved a near religious quality? America's "bought and paid for" Congress, particularly its radical right Republicans, seek to solve their nation's deficit and debt crisis on the backs of the wage earning public while protecting ruinous military spending and morally outrageous tax favouritism for the richest of the rich who now often pay effective tax rates well lower than that of low-income earners. It is this madness that has seen luxury goods flying off the shelves even as the remnants of America's once vibrant middle class reels.
It does not seem that life for most Americans will get better any time soon. Life for the few, however, will remain just dandy. What if enough Americans come to see the entire working class as set upon? What if the American street has its own Marie Antoinette moment?
There is a certain elasticity to inequality. In stable societies, inequality can expand but will then be brought back down by prudent government policy if by no other means. But if inequality expands too far and is magnified by imprudent government policy, what then? Is it unreasonable to expect the disadvantaged to angrily reject a rigged outcome that is engineered by the elite with the connivance of their governments? Is there a point in modern society where privilege becomes simply indefensible?
There are some now questioning whether the ongoing riots spreading through British cities are more than simple criminality and perhaps are harbingers of social upheaval, uprisings. Plenty of governments today wield the lash of austerity yet its sting is felt mainly by those least able to bear it, the most vulnerable - the homeless, the unemployed and the working poor. Many of these people realize that their government hasn't trimmed the sails for everyone. A privileged class exists that is, by good fortune, investment strategy and benevolent government, exempt from austerity measures, safely removed from all that.
Britain's Conservative prime minister David Cameron is waging an austerity war and it can be fairly said he's fighting it on the backs of the poorest and weakest. Yet, when the youth of this economically disenfranchised sector take to the streets to riot, Cameron dismisses it as nothing more than rank criminality. Two centuries ago the Brits knew how to deal with these types. They transported them to distant penal colonies, notably Australia. I'm sure Cameron must yearn for those good old days.
But what of the United States, where "rags'n riches" has achieved a near religious quality? America's "bought and paid for" Congress, particularly its radical right Republicans, seek to solve their nation's deficit and debt crisis on the backs of the wage earning public while protecting ruinous military spending and morally outrageous tax favouritism for the richest of the rich who now often pay effective tax rates well lower than that of low-income earners. It is this madness that has seen luxury goods flying off the shelves even as the remnants of America's once vibrant middle class reels.
It does not seem that life for most Americans will get better any time soon. Life for the few, however, will remain just dandy. What if enough Americans come to see the entire working class as set upon? What if the American street has its own Marie Antoinette moment?
There is a certain elasticity to inequality. In stable societies, inequality can expand but will then be brought back down by prudent government policy if by no other means. But if inequality expands too far and is magnified by imprudent government policy, what then? Is it unreasonable to expect the disadvantaged to angrily reject a rigged outcome that is engineered by the elite with the connivance of their governments? Is there a point in modern society where privilege becomes simply indefensible?
Tuesday, August 09, 2011
On Barack Obama, Europe is Anxiously Underwhelmed.
It's not just moderates and progressives in the United States who are losing faith in Barack Obama. So are the Europeans. Spiegel Online claims that Obama's indecision and weakness are a serious threat to the global economy.
America's president, as the political scientist Richard Neustadt once noted, may be the most powerful man in the world, but he has only one real power: the power of persuasion.
That's why US presidents are so keen to get in front of the TV cameras and address the nation from what Americans refer to as the "presidential pulpit." Barack Obama was back at the pulpit on Monday afternoon, as the world's stock exchanges plummeted. "No matter what some agency may say, we've always been and always will be a triple-A country," asserted the president. It had taken Obama three days to make a statement on Standard & Poor's decision to strip the United States of its top credit rating.
But Obama convinced no one. Even while the president was speaking, the Dow fell below 11,000 for the first time in nine months.
...The debate is transforming Obama's problem into one for the entire US. "Can America still lead?" asks Washington Post columnist E.J. Dionne Jr.. Millions of people around the world had hoped in vain that Obama "would restore the United States to a position of responsible global leadership," Dionne writes. "America's friends overseas know that the debt crisis was instigated by Obama's opponents. Yet they worry now about how strong Obama is, whether he will draw lines and if he can seize back the initiative."
Indeed, the rest of the world is displaying its uncertainty in a relatively open manner. Christine Lagarde, the new head of the International Monetary Fund, has warned that the fundamental belief in America's economic strength could be permanently undermined. Others can't resist showing schadenfreude. In a strongly worded editorial, Xinhua, China's state-run news agency, advised American leaders to show "some sense of global responsibility." Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin went even further, publicly accusing the US of "living like parasites off the global economy."
In a more ominous article, Spiegel Online ponders whether the world is going bankrupt.
Muddling through, postponing, playing down -- the motto of the crisis managers on both sides of the Atlantic has sent alarm bells ringing in stock markets. Britain's Economist magazine is warning of a double-dip recession in the US, a second downturn just three years after the last one. Many economists have been pointing out that last week's panic resembled the fear that swept financial markets after the collapse of US investment bank Lehman Brothers in September 2008.
Then as now, banks stopped lending each money. Then as now, banks' cash deposits at the central bank doubled within days. The European Central Bank reacted by assuring banks of unlimited liquidity in the coming months. It was an emergency measure that led to short-term relief but sparked anxious questions among bankers and stock market players. How long can the central bank keep up its market-soothing liquidity operations before it finally loses its credibility, the most important asset of a central bank? Is the financial crisis about to escalate? And will the world then be bankrupt?
...The scale of new borrowing is less of a problem than the inability of governments to find a credible strategy for reducing their debts. In the US, the government and opposition have been locked in a dispute over whether the deficit should be removed through tax hikes or cuts in social spending. In Europe, the solvent governments of the northern countries are refusing to underwrite the debt of the struggling Mediterranean countries.
The West faces a dual crisis that has engulfed its most important political leaders. President Barack Obama has failed to mend a gaping rift in US society and to outmaneuver the conservative Tea Party rebels. In Europe, it has become more evident with each European Union summit that German Chancellor Angela Merkel, rather than being in control of the crisis, is being driven along by it.
The West hasn't been this weak since World War II, and never before has a crisis paralyzed Europe, America and Japan at the same time. The problems of the leading industrial nations aren't just sapping the political influence of the so-called Free World, they are also threatening the global economy.
America's president, as the political scientist Richard Neustadt once noted, may be the most powerful man in the world, but he has only one real power: the power of persuasion.
That's why US presidents are so keen to get in front of the TV cameras and address the nation from what Americans refer to as the "presidential pulpit." Barack Obama was back at the pulpit on Monday afternoon, as the world's stock exchanges plummeted. "No matter what some agency may say, we've always been and always will be a triple-A country," asserted the president. It had taken Obama three days to make a statement on Standard & Poor's decision to strip the United States of its top credit rating.
But Obama convinced no one. Even while the president was speaking, the Dow fell below 11,000 for the first time in nine months.
...The debate is transforming Obama's problem into one for the entire US. "Can America still lead?" asks Washington Post columnist E.J. Dionne Jr.. Millions of people around the world had hoped in vain that Obama "would restore the United States to a position of responsible global leadership," Dionne writes. "America's friends overseas know that the debt crisis was instigated by Obama's opponents. Yet they worry now about how strong Obama is, whether he will draw lines and if he can seize back the initiative."
Indeed, the rest of the world is displaying its uncertainty in a relatively open manner. Christine Lagarde, the new head of the International Monetary Fund, has warned that the fundamental belief in America's economic strength could be permanently undermined. Others can't resist showing schadenfreude. In a strongly worded editorial, Xinhua, China's state-run news agency, advised American leaders to show "some sense of global responsibility." Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin went even further, publicly accusing the US of "living like parasites off the global economy."
In a more ominous article, Spiegel Online ponders whether the world is going bankrupt.
Muddling through, postponing, playing down -- the motto of the crisis managers on both sides of the Atlantic has sent alarm bells ringing in stock markets. Britain's Economist magazine is warning of a double-dip recession in the US, a second downturn just three years after the last one. Many economists have been pointing out that last week's panic resembled the fear that swept financial markets after the collapse of US investment bank Lehman Brothers in September 2008.
Then as now, banks stopped lending each money. Then as now, banks' cash deposits at the central bank doubled within days. The European Central Bank reacted by assuring banks of unlimited liquidity in the coming months. It was an emergency measure that led to short-term relief but sparked anxious questions among bankers and stock market players. How long can the central bank keep up its market-soothing liquidity operations before it finally loses its credibility, the most important asset of a central bank? Is the financial crisis about to escalate? And will the world then be bankrupt?
...The scale of new borrowing is less of a problem than the inability of governments to find a credible strategy for reducing their debts. In the US, the government and opposition have been locked in a dispute over whether the deficit should be removed through tax hikes or cuts in social spending. In Europe, the solvent governments of the northern countries are refusing to underwrite the debt of the struggling Mediterranean countries.
The West faces a dual crisis that has engulfed its most important political leaders. President Barack Obama has failed to mend a gaping rift in US society and to outmaneuver the conservative Tea Party rebels. In Europe, it has become more evident with each European Union summit that German Chancellor Angela Merkel, rather than being in control of the crisis, is being driven along by it.
The West hasn't been this weak since World War II, and never before has a crisis paralyzed Europe, America and Japan at the same time. The problems of the leading industrial nations aren't just sapping the political influence of the so-called Free World, they are also threatening the global economy.
China Now Wants a Military Presence in Pakistan Tribal Areas
In the wake of two terrorist bombings in Xinjiang province, China wants to hunt down Uyghur militants it claims are being trained in Pakistan's ungovernable tribal areas.
Since the blasts, which killed 18, Chinese officials have publicly claimed for the first time in recent years that the attackers were trained in explosives in camps run by the al-Qaeda-linked East Turkestan Islamic Movement (ETIM).
Though the ETIM network on the AfPak border was significantly weakened in recent years in the wake of the deaths of many of its top leaders in United States drone attacks, hardcore Uyghur
militants are still shuttling between China and Pakistan since Xinjiang province shares a border with Pakistan.
The ETIM, which is run by natives of Xinjiang province, a Muslim-dominated region three times the size of France, is fighting against the settlement of China's majority Han ethnic group in the western province, describing its struggle as a freedom movement.
In neighbouring, dysfunctional Afghanistan, more than a year after general elections there is still a dispute over who is legally entitled to sit in parliament. A special tribunal created by Hamid Karzai has decided a quarter of the legislators should be removed. Those opposed to Karzai claim the tribunal is illegal. Is it any wonder the Taliban are having a field day?
Since the blasts, which killed 18, Chinese officials have publicly claimed for the first time in recent years that the attackers were trained in explosives in camps run by the al-Qaeda-linked East Turkestan Islamic Movement (ETIM).
Though the ETIM network on the AfPak border was significantly weakened in recent years in the wake of the deaths of many of its top leaders in United States drone attacks, hardcore Uyghur
militants are still shuttling between China and Pakistan since Xinjiang province shares a border with Pakistan.
The ETIM, which is run by natives of Xinjiang province, a Muslim-dominated region three times the size of France, is fighting against the settlement of China's majority Han ethnic group in the western province, describing its struggle as a freedom movement.
In neighbouring, dysfunctional Afghanistan, more than a year after general elections there is still a dispute over who is legally entitled to sit in parliament. A special tribunal created by Hamid Karzai has decided a quarter of the legislators should be removed. Those opposed to Karzai claim the tribunal is illegal. Is it any wonder the Taliban are having a field day?
English Riots Metastasize
England has sustained its third night of widespread rioting and looting. What began as an isolated uprising over a police shooting in Tottenham has rapidly spread to other greater London buroughs including Enfield, Islington and Oxford Circus Monday night and to Peckham, Clapham, Lewisham, Bromley, Stratford, Croydon, East Ham, Bethnall Green,Woolich and even the Medway town of Gillingham last night. What appear to be copycat riots also spread to Liverpool, Birmingham and Bristol.
David Cameron has cut short a holiday in Tuscany and is recalling Parliament to deal with the unrest. Police officers are being drawn to the riot sites from across Britain and all leaves have been canceled.
What began as a protest against one police shooting in one London burough seems to have triggered widespread fury, perhaps even anarchy. Handling this and containing the further spread of these riots will be a major test of the Cameron government. This could go very wrong, very quickly.
David Cameron has cut short a holiday in Tuscany and is recalling Parliament to deal with the unrest. Police officers are being drawn to the riot sites from across Britain and all leaves have been canceled.
What began as a protest against one police shooting in one London burough seems to have triggered widespread fury, perhaps even anarchy. Handling this and containing the further spread of these riots will be a major test of the Cameron government. This could go very wrong, very quickly.
Russia Burns - Again
Last year a powerful heat wave triggered massive forest fires in Russia and led to the failure of Russia's wheat crop. So far this year, 1-million hectares of Russian forests have been burned out, already breaking last year's record.
The far north of Russia is among the areas that have suffered the most. During the last week of July, Arkhangelsk and the Komi republic had temperatures exceeding 35C. More than 80 fire outbreaks were reported.
The far east has suffered too. At the beginning of August about 50 fires were raging, especially around Khabarovsk, Yakutsk and the island of Sakhalin. Southern Russia has not escaped: several villages have been evacuated around Rostov-on-Don and Volgograd, where temperatures rose above 40C in July.
Of course this has nothing to do with global warming which we all know is a hoax. Greenpeace, meanwhile, says bad as the official figures are, the Russian government is understating the extent of these fires which, according to Greenpeace, is plain from satellite images.
The far north of Russia is among the areas that have suffered the most. During the last week of July, Arkhangelsk and the Komi republic had temperatures exceeding 35C. More than 80 fire outbreaks were reported.
The far east has suffered too. At the beginning of August about 50 fires were raging, especially around Khabarovsk, Yakutsk and the island of Sakhalin. Southern Russia has not escaped: several villages have been evacuated around Rostov-on-Don and Volgograd, where temperatures rose above 40C in July.
Of course this has nothing to do with global warming which we all know is a hoax. Greenpeace, meanwhile, says bad as the official figures are, the Russian government is understating the extent of these fires which, according to Greenpeace, is plain from satellite images.
What Michelle Bachmann Watched on Sunday
Oh those crazy foaming fundamentalist rightwingers and their homophobia.
On Sunday, Bachmann and her curious husband, attended a church service at which the pastor railed on, denouncing homosexuality as "unnatural" and "immoral." At the end of the sermon the congregation got to watch this video of Adam Hood, a self-proclaimed "ex gay."
Think Progress reports that the marriage of religious fundamentalism and state corporatism got a boost at the recent ALEC conference in New Orleans. State legislators attending the American Legislative Exchange Council, where Big Business hands compliant legislators draft legislation to take home and implement, were also given anti-LGBT literature in their handouts. The pamphlets, produced by the Family Research Center, were entitled the “Top Ten Myths About Homosexuality” and the “Top Ten Harms Of Same-Sex ‘Marriage”.
Doing her furious fundamentalist best for the advancement of corporatism, Michelle Bachmann has pledged that, if only enough crazy people vote to put her in office, she'll lock the doors and turn out the lights at the Environmental Protection Agency which she slams as the greatest job killer in America.
On Sunday, Bachmann and her curious husband, attended a church service at which the pastor railed on, denouncing homosexuality as "unnatural" and "immoral." At the end of the sermon the congregation got to watch this video of Adam Hood, a self-proclaimed "ex gay."
Think Progress reports that the marriage of religious fundamentalism and state corporatism got a boost at the recent ALEC conference in New Orleans. State legislators attending the American Legislative Exchange Council, where Big Business hands compliant legislators draft legislation to take home and implement, were also given anti-LGBT literature in their handouts. The pamphlets, produced by the Family Research Center, were entitled the “Top Ten Myths About Homosexuality” and the “Top Ten Harms Of Same-Sex ‘Marriage”.
Doing her furious fundamentalist best for the advancement of corporatism, Michelle Bachmann has pledged that, if only enough crazy people vote to put her in office, she'll lock the doors and turn out the lights at the Environmental Protection Agency which she slams as the greatest job killer in America.
Monday, August 08, 2011
The Real Enemy Isn't Debt, It's Globalization
Globalization has always been a scam. It has always been a trade of something very valuable for a vague and quite unenforceable promise of enormous benefits for all. What we traded away was sovereignty, our sovereign right to control access to our markets, our right to employ tariffs as an instrument of state policy. And we surrendered that to just whom exactly? Well to corporations, multi-national corporations that have such a terrific track record of honouring vague, unenforceable promises. Now power has shifted, irretrievably, from nation state to corporation. Nowhere is this more evident than in the United States with its "bought and paid for" Congress implementing corporatism at the expense of democracy.
An analysis published in The Guardian reveals that our leaders not only surrendered our sovereignty but abrogated their ongoing but unmentioned responsibility to maintain control of globalization.
After relying on it to deliver years of growth, lift millions from poverty, keep living standards rising and citizens happy, nation states look to have lost control of globalization.
In the short term, that leaves policymakers looking impotent in the face of fast-moving markets and other uncontrolled and perhaps uncontrollable systems -- undermining their authority and potentially helping fuel a wider backlash and social unrest.
..."In times of economic recession, countries tend to become isolationist and retrench from globalization," says Celina Realuyo, assistant professor of National Security affairs at the US National Defense University in Washington DC.
"Given the increased number of stakeholders on any issue -- climate change, the global financial system, cyber security -- it is unclear how traditional nation states can lead on any issue, let alone build consensus globally," she said.
The financial system, the Internet and even the supply chains for natural resources have quietly slipped beyond effective forms of state control.
These instruments of globalization have delivered huge wealth and kept economies moving with arguably greater efficiency, but can also swiftly turn on those in authority.
...It's unlikely that nations can genuinely pull back from globalised systems on which they have become reliant.
"The Net sees censorship as damage and routes around it," computer science guru John Gilmore said in 1993. In the modern, high-speed globalised system, one could say the same of attempts at financial and economic restrictions.
Many areas of the global economy have also become effectively "ungoverned space" into which a host of actors -- from criminals to international firms such as Google and Goldman Sachs to countless other individuals and groups -- have enthusiastically jumped.
International companies and rich individuals move money -- and even entire manufacturing operations -- from jurisdiction to jurisdiction to seek low wages, avoid tax, regulation and sometimes even detection. In many states, that helped fuel a growing wealth gap that is self producing new tensions.
..."For most of the last decade, growth and economic activity in many places has been driven by forces that were inherently unsustainable," says Simon Derrick, head of foreign exchange at Bank of New York Mellon.
"What's happening now is these... are coming under pressure and it's getting to the stage where that can no longer be ignored. But none of these issues are going to be politically easy to do anything about."
And yet we will struggle back against globalization and we will win if only because the result is essentially pre-ordained. Global corporatism, let's call it what it truly is, functions on a construct of assumptions that are increasingly at odds with reality. It is based on economic models well suited to the 19th and 20th centuries that are losing credence in the 21st.
During the 20th century mankind tripled in population but consumption increased six fold. And in the first decade of the 21st century, the consumption footprint of the emerging economic superpowers has added enormously to this burden. For globalization that would be great if only there was plenty to go around, more than enough resources to exploit. But that's not the case. We've run into a wall, actually a succession of walls. In the process we will inevitably shift from growth-based economies into allocation-based societies. Growth has been a powerful salve to soothe the less-desirable impacts of globalization but once we reach the growth limits of our inescapably finite planet, the balance shifts and globalization takes on the visage of a predatory scourge.
The way ahead for global corporations probably lies in global corporatism, the rise of the corporate state. There are eerie signs that the lines are already being drawn with corporatism forging alliances with the political far right, the religious radical right and the emerging political militarism. This has been well chronicled by the likes of Andrew Bacevich, Chalmers Johnson, Chomsky and others. That presents the prospect of an intense struggle to preserve democracy that may be faced by our children and grandchildren even as they're being powerfully conditioned to embrace indifference, apathy and submissiveness.
The growth of state corporatism is rarely recognized for the actual threat to democracy it poses. State corporatism, as in the case of America's "bought and paid for" Congress, seeks to implement, domestically, what globalization has achieved abroad such as low wages, tax exemptions, and gutted labour and environmental regulation. That is precisely what organizations such as ALEC, the American Legislative Exchange Council, exist to achieve. It is the vehicle by which corporatism obtains direct, political power. The corporatist cabal is now actually writing bills for compliant legislators to enact. Public interest is tossed out the window when corporate interest prevails.
An analysis published in The Guardian reveals that our leaders not only surrendered our sovereignty but abrogated their ongoing but unmentioned responsibility to maintain control of globalization.
After relying on it to deliver years of growth, lift millions from poverty, keep living standards rising and citizens happy, nation states look to have lost control of globalization.
In the short term, that leaves policymakers looking impotent in the face of fast-moving markets and other uncontrolled and perhaps uncontrollable systems -- undermining their authority and potentially helping fuel a wider backlash and social unrest.
..."In times of economic recession, countries tend to become isolationist and retrench from globalization," says Celina Realuyo, assistant professor of National Security affairs at the US National Defense University in Washington DC.
"Given the increased number of stakeholders on any issue -- climate change, the global financial system, cyber security -- it is unclear how traditional nation states can lead on any issue, let alone build consensus globally," she said.
The financial system, the Internet and even the supply chains for natural resources have quietly slipped beyond effective forms of state control.
These instruments of globalization have delivered huge wealth and kept economies moving with arguably greater efficiency, but can also swiftly turn on those in authority.
...It's unlikely that nations can genuinely pull back from globalised systems on which they have become reliant.
"The Net sees censorship as damage and routes around it," computer science guru John Gilmore said in 1993. In the modern, high-speed globalised system, one could say the same of attempts at financial and economic restrictions.
Many areas of the global economy have also become effectively "ungoverned space" into which a host of actors -- from criminals to international firms such as Google and Goldman Sachs to countless other individuals and groups -- have enthusiastically jumped.
International companies and rich individuals move money -- and even entire manufacturing operations -- from jurisdiction to jurisdiction to seek low wages, avoid tax, regulation and sometimes even detection. In many states, that helped fuel a growing wealth gap that is self producing new tensions.
..."For most of the last decade, growth and economic activity in many places has been driven by forces that were inherently unsustainable," says Simon Derrick, head of foreign exchange at Bank of New York Mellon.
"What's happening now is these... are coming under pressure and it's getting to the stage where that can no longer be ignored. But none of these issues are going to be politically easy to do anything about."
And yet we will struggle back against globalization and we will win if only because the result is essentially pre-ordained. Global corporatism, let's call it what it truly is, functions on a construct of assumptions that are increasingly at odds with reality. It is based on economic models well suited to the 19th and 20th centuries that are losing credence in the 21st.
During the 20th century mankind tripled in population but consumption increased six fold. And in the first decade of the 21st century, the consumption footprint of the emerging economic superpowers has added enormously to this burden. For globalization that would be great if only there was plenty to go around, more than enough resources to exploit. But that's not the case. We've run into a wall, actually a succession of walls. In the process we will inevitably shift from growth-based economies into allocation-based societies. Growth has been a powerful salve to soothe the less-desirable impacts of globalization but once we reach the growth limits of our inescapably finite planet, the balance shifts and globalization takes on the visage of a predatory scourge.
The way ahead for global corporations probably lies in global corporatism, the rise of the corporate state. There are eerie signs that the lines are already being drawn with corporatism forging alliances with the political far right, the religious radical right and the emerging political militarism. This has been well chronicled by the likes of Andrew Bacevich, Chalmers Johnson, Chomsky and others. That presents the prospect of an intense struggle to preserve democracy that may be faced by our children and grandchildren even as they're being powerfully conditioned to embrace indifference, apathy and submissiveness.
The growth of state corporatism is rarely recognized for the actual threat to democracy it poses. State corporatism, as in the case of America's "bought and paid for" Congress, seeks to implement, domestically, what globalization has achieved abroad such as low wages, tax exemptions, and gutted labour and environmental regulation. That is precisely what organizations such as ALEC, the American Legislative Exchange Council, exist to achieve. It is the vehicle by which corporatism obtains direct, political power. The corporatist cabal is now actually writing bills for compliant legislators to enact. Public interest is tossed out the window when corporate interest prevails.
When It Comes Right Down to It, It's Mainly a Con Game
Modern, consumer economies are essentially a confidence game. When confidence is high, money flows; goods are produced, sold and bought; and we all (sort of) enjoy the boom. When confidence is low, that all comes undone. The public becomes fearful and stops buying; manufacturers stop producing and lay off workers and then we set up soup kitchens and bread lines.
Yet sometimes confidence isn't enough. Sometimes economies can get so out of whack that illusions can't suffice to hide it. And that's where the great ratings agencies - Moody's, Standard & Poor's, and Fitch Ratings - come in. Investors look to them to gauge the credit risk of debt instruments, including government bonds or "treasuries."
The agencies are busy these days evaluating the credit worthiness of a lot of fiscally troubled nations such as Iceland, Ireland, Greece, Spain, Italy and even the United States. S&P created quite a stir when it downgraded America's credit rating from AAA to AA+. But just how safe are these agencies when they're dishing the dirty on powerful governments?
Governments can counterattack when they don't hear what they like from credit rating agencies. The Obama administration fought back against S&P, even arguing that the agency used faulty math to reach skewed conclusions. They specifically attacked Standard & Poor's 'credibility and integrity.' S&P must have run their numbers again because they're sticking with their rating.
Yet in the land of all things Berlusconi, Italian police acting on orders from state prosecutors raided the offices of Moody's and Standard and Poor's. The cops say they're investigating the role these agencies played in Italy's recent financial turmoil. It's a pretty chilling message - "cross us and you can expect a criminal investigation." Intimidation? It sure as hell sounds like it.
It makes you wonder whether today's real con artists, those we most need to worry about, aren't rank and file swindlers but our governments. It seems that ever since 9/11 they've become more secretive, less accountable and much less democratic. That is quite true of our own authoritarian government and its autocratic Ruler. When it comes to sleight of hand and bait and switch, Harper is a highly accomplished con artist.
We used to hold that people shouldn't fear their government; their government should fear the people. In some intangible ways and some very tangible ways I sense that's slipping away from us.
Yet sometimes confidence isn't enough. Sometimes economies can get so out of whack that illusions can't suffice to hide it. And that's where the great ratings agencies - Moody's, Standard & Poor's, and Fitch Ratings - come in. Investors look to them to gauge the credit risk of debt instruments, including government bonds or "treasuries."
The agencies are busy these days evaluating the credit worthiness of a lot of fiscally troubled nations such as Iceland, Ireland, Greece, Spain, Italy and even the United States. S&P created quite a stir when it downgraded America's credit rating from AAA to AA+. But just how safe are these agencies when they're dishing the dirty on powerful governments?
Governments can counterattack when they don't hear what they like from credit rating agencies. The Obama administration fought back against S&P, even arguing that the agency used faulty math to reach skewed conclusions. They specifically attacked Standard & Poor's 'credibility and integrity.' S&P must have run their numbers again because they're sticking with their rating.
Yet in the land of all things Berlusconi, Italian police acting on orders from state prosecutors raided the offices of Moody's and Standard and Poor's. The cops say they're investigating the role these agencies played in Italy's recent financial turmoil. It's a pretty chilling message - "cross us and you can expect a criminal investigation." Intimidation? It sure as hell sounds like it.
It makes you wonder whether today's real con artists, those we most need to worry about, aren't rank and file swindlers but our governments. It seems that ever since 9/11 they've become more secretive, less accountable and much less democratic. That is quite true of our own authoritarian government and its autocratic Ruler. When it comes to sleight of hand and bait and switch, Harper is a highly accomplished con artist.
We used to hold that people shouldn't fear their government; their government should fear the people. In some intangible ways and some very tangible ways I sense that's slipping away from us.
Sunday, August 07, 2011
Showdown for America
It's crunch time for America. China is getting tired of picking up America's bar tab and has put the US on notice that the days of cheap booze may soon be over. No more bad cheques, thank you very much and absolutely no more rowdy brawls in Congress either.
The Bush years were a national piss up like no other. Cheney said Reagan had shown that "deficits don't matter" and he meant it. The Republicans, aided by a good many Democrats, went at it like mining camp whores on payday. In just two terms in office, Bush almost tripled America's national debt. al Qaeda only managed to bring down two office towers. Bush Republicans brought down the entire country. In the process they completed the greatest unearned transfer of wealth in their country's history by fleecing the blue and white collar working classes and facilitating the transfer of their wealth and the fruits of their productivity to the richest of the rich, leaving a near bottomless chasm of inequality in their wake. But, remember, those were the good times.
Those good times are over. Recklessness comes with a price and it's often pretty ugly. We're only now getting the full measure of their fiscal perfidy. Imagine taking the world's sole super military establishment and swelling that to the point of bloating. Imagine waging two wars (and wars without end at that) against relatively backward states and running up a tab exceeding what you spent in WWII. Imagine financing that massive military expansion and financing those wars with masses of money borrowed from foreign lenders. And then imagine slashing taxes for the richest of the rich, wealth you can only forgo by yet further borrowing from foreign lenders. Imagine slashing taxes for anybody when you're already deeply in hock. It's nothing short of breathtaking.
Recklessness was the gold standard of the Bush Republicans. It was their stock in trade. Having largely completed Reagan's work in divesting America of her manufacturing base, the Bush Republicans set about to deregulate their country's new economy, its utterly parasitic FIRE (finance/insurance/real estate) economy. Henceforth wealth would be created not by actually producing goods but through inducing illusions. Prosperity would be a perception crafted out of seemingly limitless amounts of money borrowed at ridiculously low interest rates. These enabled asset values (illusion) to become detached from and race ahead of true worth (reality). It felt the same. Hell it felt good and it came with the promise that it was just going to go on and on and on forever. The promises that flowed from America's political and corporate elite were about as reliable as promises from a crack dealer and they were very bit as destructive.
Now the question is whether what's left of America's blue and white collar working class will be broken on the wheel in an orgy of deficit fighting. The narrative of the upcoming campaign is already being framed. Spending cuts are on the table. Tax restoration for America's new aristocracy definitely is not. This pain is not for those who can most easily bear it and, in all fairness, deserve it. This pain is reserved for their underclasses. Those who will wield the lash are the Congressional minions of the aristocracy, the elite's new House of Lords.
Congress will attack America's working classes by stripping them of their "entitlements." Blue and White collar America will see their social safety net, their Social Security and Medicare benefits, rejigged to reduce eligibility and coverage. That is where money will be found, in the very place it does not exist.
Working Americans funded their Social Security entitlements through their payroll taxes. Those monies were to have been held "in trust" by their government. The United States government became the fiduciary for every employee who remitted payroll taxes. This is a very special type of debt. We even have a specific word to describe the wrongful taking of trust money by a fiduciary, "defalcation." We consider it so egregious that we provide in our bankruptcy laws that a debt arising out of defalcation shall not be expunged by a debtor's discharge from bankruptcy. The debt survives even bankruptcy.
But, it seems, when outright defalcation is committed by Congress it doesn't matter, perhaps because the federal government was stealing from, cheating every member of the working classes. Now, having done that, they intend to compound the suffering inflicted on working Americans by preserving a tax dodge scheme implemented for the new aristocracy. "Unmitigated gall" isn't remotely adequate to describe what is about to be visited on blue and white collar America and the tattered remnants of her once vibrant and robust middle class.
It's probably too late now to change any of this. You won't get this sort of change from a "bought and paid for" Congress. Early in the Bush years Karl Rove let slip that it was part of his neo-conservative dream that the American government should be de-funded. That way, he opined, it would be forced to scrap the entire progressive legacy of Franklin Roosevelt. And that dream has become today's reality. The government is defunded, the middle class is a spent force, and the populace has been conditioned to recoil from its own best interests. As Bill Maher puts it, they throw up their hands and yell, "Jesus, take the wheel."
About a decade ago I pondered whether China, had it sought to hasten America's decline and its own economic, political and military ascendancy, could have devised two better weapons than globalization and debt? Sap America of its manufacturing base and use the wealth thereby generated to transform America into the world's greatest debtor state and China into America's major creditor. Who needs missiles or bombs when your rival will so freely cooperate in its own decline even as it facilitates your own ascent? I'm still far from convinced this was not China's intent from the outset. At this point I suppose that no longer matters. It is what it is.
I'm more than a little angry about this. An impoverished America on our doorstep is something of a threat to our own social stability. There are those in our country who would happily emulate cherry-picked elements of American policy. This is going to be a very challenging century for every nation and, for many regions, it will be far more than merely challenging. This is the time when we will need the strongest, most responsive democracies and institutions, capable of resisting the powerful temptations of authoritarianism and oligarchy. Yet we seem to be heading in the exact opposite direction.
The Bush years were a national piss up like no other. Cheney said Reagan had shown that "deficits don't matter" and he meant it. The Republicans, aided by a good many Democrats, went at it like mining camp whores on payday. In just two terms in office, Bush almost tripled America's national debt. al Qaeda only managed to bring down two office towers. Bush Republicans brought down the entire country. In the process they completed the greatest unearned transfer of wealth in their country's history by fleecing the blue and white collar working classes and facilitating the transfer of their wealth and the fruits of their productivity to the richest of the rich, leaving a near bottomless chasm of inequality in their wake. But, remember, those were the good times.
Those good times are over. Recklessness comes with a price and it's often pretty ugly. We're only now getting the full measure of their fiscal perfidy. Imagine taking the world's sole super military establishment and swelling that to the point of bloating. Imagine waging two wars (and wars without end at that) against relatively backward states and running up a tab exceeding what you spent in WWII. Imagine financing that massive military expansion and financing those wars with masses of money borrowed from foreign lenders. And then imagine slashing taxes for the richest of the rich, wealth you can only forgo by yet further borrowing from foreign lenders. Imagine slashing taxes for anybody when you're already deeply in hock. It's nothing short of breathtaking.
Recklessness was the gold standard of the Bush Republicans. It was their stock in trade. Having largely completed Reagan's work in divesting America of her manufacturing base, the Bush Republicans set about to deregulate their country's new economy, its utterly parasitic FIRE (finance/insurance/real estate) economy. Henceforth wealth would be created not by actually producing goods but through inducing illusions. Prosperity would be a perception crafted out of seemingly limitless amounts of money borrowed at ridiculously low interest rates. These enabled asset values (illusion) to become detached from and race ahead of true worth (reality). It felt the same. Hell it felt good and it came with the promise that it was just going to go on and on and on forever. The promises that flowed from America's political and corporate elite were about as reliable as promises from a crack dealer and they were very bit as destructive.
Now the question is whether what's left of America's blue and white collar working class will be broken on the wheel in an orgy of deficit fighting. The narrative of the upcoming campaign is already being framed. Spending cuts are on the table. Tax restoration for America's new aristocracy definitely is not. This pain is not for those who can most easily bear it and, in all fairness, deserve it. This pain is reserved for their underclasses. Those who will wield the lash are the Congressional minions of the aristocracy, the elite's new House of Lords.
Congress will attack America's working classes by stripping them of their "entitlements." Blue and White collar America will see their social safety net, their Social Security and Medicare benefits, rejigged to reduce eligibility and coverage. That is where money will be found, in the very place it does not exist.
Working Americans funded their Social Security entitlements through their payroll taxes. Those monies were to have been held "in trust" by their government. The United States government became the fiduciary for every employee who remitted payroll taxes. This is a very special type of debt. We even have a specific word to describe the wrongful taking of trust money by a fiduciary, "defalcation." We consider it so egregious that we provide in our bankruptcy laws that a debt arising out of defalcation shall not be expunged by a debtor's discharge from bankruptcy. The debt survives even bankruptcy.
But, it seems, when outright defalcation is committed by Congress it doesn't matter, perhaps because the federal government was stealing from, cheating every member of the working classes. Now, having done that, they intend to compound the suffering inflicted on working Americans by preserving a tax dodge scheme implemented for the new aristocracy. "Unmitigated gall" isn't remotely adequate to describe what is about to be visited on blue and white collar America and the tattered remnants of her once vibrant and robust middle class.
It's probably too late now to change any of this. You won't get this sort of change from a "bought and paid for" Congress. Early in the Bush years Karl Rove let slip that it was part of his neo-conservative dream that the American government should be de-funded. That way, he opined, it would be forced to scrap the entire progressive legacy of Franklin Roosevelt. And that dream has become today's reality. The government is defunded, the middle class is a spent force, and the populace has been conditioned to recoil from its own best interests. As Bill Maher puts it, they throw up their hands and yell, "Jesus, take the wheel."
About a decade ago I pondered whether China, had it sought to hasten America's decline and its own economic, political and military ascendancy, could have devised two better weapons than globalization and debt? Sap America of its manufacturing base and use the wealth thereby generated to transform America into the world's greatest debtor state and China into America's major creditor. Who needs missiles or bombs when your rival will so freely cooperate in its own decline even as it facilitates your own ascent? I'm still far from convinced this was not China's intent from the outset. At this point I suppose that no longer matters. It is what it is.
I'm more than a little angry about this. An impoverished America on our doorstep is something of a threat to our own social stability. There are those in our country who would happily emulate cherry-picked elements of American policy. This is going to be a very challenging century for every nation and, for many regions, it will be far more than merely challenging. This is the time when we will need the strongest, most responsive democracies and institutions, capable of resisting the powerful temptations of authoritarianism and oligarchy. Yet we seem to be heading in the exact opposite direction.
Saturday, August 06, 2011
The "Good Old Days" Are Over - China Warns U.S.
America's biggest creditor isn't amused by that country's newly downgraded, AA+ rating. Now China says the "good old days" are over for the U.S.
China has renewed its demand for a new reserve currency to replace the U.S. greenback. America dreads the thought at having to borrow - and repay - money in another nation's currency. All manner of advantages accrue to the United States so long as its dollar is accepted as the reserve currency.
"The U.S. government has to come to terms with the painful fact that the good old days when it could just borrow its way out of messes of its own making are finally gone," China's official Xinhua news agency said in a commentary.
In the Xinhua commentary, China scorned the United States for its "debt addiction" and "short sighted" political wrangling.
"China, the largest creditor of the world's sole superpower, has every right now to demand the United States address its structural debt problems and ensure the safety of China's dollar assets," it said.
It urged the United States to cut military and social welfare expenditure. Further credit downgrades would very likely undermine the world economic recovery and trigger new rounds of financial turmoil, it said.
"International supervision over the issue of U.S. dollars should be introduced and a new, stable and secured global reserve currency may also be an option to avert a catastrophe caused by any single country," Xinhua said.
China has renewed its demand for a new reserve currency to replace the U.S. greenback. America dreads the thought at having to borrow - and repay - money in another nation's currency. All manner of advantages accrue to the United States so long as its dollar is accepted as the reserve currency.
"The U.S. government has to come to terms with the painful fact that the good old days when it could just borrow its way out of messes of its own making are finally gone," China's official Xinhua news agency said in a commentary.
In the Xinhua commentary, China scorned the United States for its "debt addiction" and "short sighted" political wrangling.
"China, the largest creditor of the world's sole superpower, has every right now to demand the United States address its structural debt problems and ensure the safety of China's dollar assets," it said.
It urged the United States to cut military and social welfare expenditure. Further credit downgrades would very likely undermine the world economic recovery and trigger new rounds of financial turmoil, it said.
"International supervision over the issue of U.S. dollars should be introduced and a new, stable and secured global reserve currency may also be an option to avert a catastrophe caused by any single country," Xinhua said.
Will Canada Destroy Civilization?
We have to choose - will it be the survival of mankind or will it be whatever wealth we can extract from the Athabasca Tar Sands? It seems to be an "either-or" proposition, at least according to a leading voice on global warming, the NASA Goddard Space Laboratory director James Hansen.
Hansen's warning, in a letter he wrote in June, is about as stark as it gets:
...exploitation of tar sands would make it implausible to stabilize climate and avoid disastrous global climate impacts. The tar sands are estimated (e.g., see IPCC AR4 WG3 report) to contain at least 400 GtC (equivalent to about 200 ppm CO2).
Easily available reserves of conventional oil and gas are enough to take atmospheric CO2
well above 400 ppm. However, if emissions from coal are phased out over the next few decades
and if unconventional fossil fuels are left in the ground, it is conceivable to stabilize climate.
Phase out of emissions from coal is itself an enormous challenge. However, if the tar
sands are thrown into the mix it is essentially game over. There is no practical way to capture
the CO2 emitted while burning oil, which is used principally in vehicles.
Governments are acting as if they are oblivious to the fact that there is a limit on how
much fossil fuel carbon we can put into the air. Fossil fuel carbon injected into the atmosphere
will stay in surface reservoirs for millennia.
...prior government targets for limiting human-made global warming are now known to be
inadequate. Specifically, the target to limit global warming to 2°C, rather than being a safe
"guardrail", is actually a recipe for global climate disasters.
When will Bob Rae and whoever is leading the NDP next week stand up and say that Athabasca has to be stopped? Yes, that would have significant impacts on Alberta's economy and the federal government's larder but that pales into irrelevance when contrasted with the toll that Tar Sands emissions will exact on the people of our planet, especially those who are already reeling from climate change effects caused by global warming. Others pay for our windfall with their lives. By what moral right can we demand they forfeit their future, their very lives? Just what sort of creatures have we Canadians become?
Bill McKibbon asked that very question last month in The Globe & Mail. How did Canadians allow themselves to become defined by the bitumen pits of Fort Mac? Why have we chosen to become indifferent to the point of catatonic? How did we come to turn our backs on our own future generations and mankind itself?
Hansen's warning, in a letter he wrote in June, is about as stark as it gets:
...exploitation of tar sands would make it implausible to stabilize climate and avoid disastrous global climate impacts. The tar sands are estimated (e.g., see IPCC AR4 WG3 report) to contain at least 400 GtC (equivalent to about 200 ppm CO2).
Easily available reserves of conventional oil and gas are enough to take atmospheric CO2
well above 400 ppm. However, if emissions from coal are phased out over the next few decades
and if unconventional fossil fuels are left in the ground, it is conceivable to stabilize climate.
Phase out of emissions from coal is itself an enormous challenge. However, if the tar
sands are thrown into the mix it is essentially game over. There is no practical way to capture
the CO2 emitted while burning oil, which is used principally in vehicles.
Governments are acting as if they are oblivious to the fact that there is a limit on how
much fossil fuel carbon we can put into the air. Fossil fuel carbon injected into the atmosphere
will stay in surface reservoirs for millennia.
...prior government targets for limiting human-made global warming are now known to be
inadequate. Specifically, the target to limit global warming to 2°C, rather than being a safe
"guardrail", is actually a recipe for global climate disasters.
When will Bob Rae and whoever is leading the NDP next week stand up and say that Athabasca has to be stopped? Yes, that would have significant impacts on Alberta's economy and the federal government's larder but that pales into irrelevance when contrasted with the toll that Tar Sands emissions will exact on the people of our planet, especially those who are already reeling from climate change effects caused by global warming. Others pay for our windfall with their lives. By what moral right can we demand they forfeit their future, their very lives? Just what sort of creatures have we Canadians become?
Bill McKibbon asked that very question last month in The Globe & Mail. How did Canadians allow themselves to become defined by the bitumen pits of Fort Mac? Why have we chosen to become indifferent to the point of catatonic? How did we come to turn our backs on our own future generations and mankind itself?
Wednesday, August 03, 2011
Corrupters' Coven Assembles Today in New Orleans
![]() |
| Bush Greeting ALEC, 2007 |
State legislators from every corner of America are flocking to New Orleans today, summoned to the Big Easy by ALEC, the American Legislative Exchange Council. ALEC is the clearing house for Big Business's legislative whims. Elected officials show up for a closed door session, get their marching orders in the form of business-proposed legislation, collect their parting gifts and return to their respective assemblies to do as they're damned well told and bugger the voting public.
PR Watch reports industry giants such as Koch Industries, Bayer, Kraft, Coca-Cola, State farm, AT&T, WalMart and Philip Morris will be on hand to unveil their wish list legislation.
ALEC is little more than a bill factory for corporate-friendly legislation that often repeals people’s rights or fattens the corporate bottom line. We think citizens have a right to know that these Fortune 100 firms “have a voice and a vote” through ALEC on bills before they are introduced in state houses, cleansed of the fact that corporations already voted on them. ALEC’s hot bills lately have sought to require voter ID, promote tobacco products flavored to appeal to kids, privatize Medicare and Medicaid, privatize prisons and public schools, and legalize the harassment of immigrants.
ALEC’s arsenal includes bills to make it harder for people to band together to negotiate with employers through unions. The ALEC “Public Employee Bargaining Transparency Act,” proposed by Rep. Anthony Ligi (as HB204), was rationalized on the claim that “Increased transparency in labor negotiation meetings and documents serves to provide all parties to the negotiations with an incentive to avoid any hint of corruption; Open sessions and increased oversight help ensure that government is using taxpayer money effectively.” Perhaps Ligi will sponsor a bill to open ALEC's task force meetings, where corporations and legislators vote, to similar sunshine and require disclosure of ALEC’s corporate donors “to avoid any hint of corruption,” especially since taxpayers pay many legislators’ ALEC dues.
Cash-strapped, as in all but bankrupt, Louisiana is forking out $50,000 for 31 legislators to attend the ALEC conference in - Louisiana.
Only in America, eh?
Tuesday, August 02, 2011
Three Qualities Obama Lacks - Convictions, Courage and Strength
In just over 15-months Americans will choose their next president. At this point Barack Obama's future hinges on the Republicans fielding a really terrible candidate, somebody like Michelle Bachmann. In other words, Obama will likely win only by default.
As Brookings Institute analyst William Galston observes, there are two qualities Americans need from their president, both of them Obama came up short on in the debt debacle.
"Most Americans will accept a president with whom they disagree. Above all, they want two things from the occupant of the Oval Office—a core of convictions they can understand and the strength to fight for them."
Galston provides a thoughtful analysis of Obama's mis-steps in the debt/deficit fiasco and how he allowed control of the agenda to be pulled from his fingers.
As Brookings Institute analyst William Galston observes, there are two qualities Americans need from their president, both of them Obama came up short on in the debt debacle.
"Most Americans will accept a president with whom they disagree. Above all, they want two things from the occupant of the Oval Office—a core of convictions they can understand and the strength to fight for them."
Galston provides a thoughtful analysis of Obama's mis-steps in the debt/deficit fiasco and how he allowed control of the agenda to be pulled from his fingers.
Any Port In a Storm, Even the NDP
How does somebody who has been a Dipper for six months get to lead the NDP? Better yet, how does someone who was a separatist supporter just six months ago rise to NDP leadership?
Is the NDP so bereft of leadership talent that it has to appoint someone who, as recently as six months ago, was anti-federalist? According to Wiki, during her tenure as leader of the Public Service Alliance of Canada, Nycole Turmel, encouraged Quebec members to vote for the Bloc.
It sounds as though Turmel saw the writing on the wall for the Bloc and figured her best shot for getting a seat in Parliament was to jump to the NDP. And now, she's leader - acting Leader of the loyal(?) Opposition. Yippee!
Is the NDP so bereft of leadership talent that it has to appoint someone who, as recently as six months ago, was anti-federalist? According to Wiki, during her tenure as leader of the Public Service Alliance of Canada, Nycole Turmel, encouraged Quebec members to vote for the Bloc.
It sounds as though Turmel saw the writing on the wall for the Bloc and figured her best shot for getting a seat in Parliament was to jump to the NDP. And now, she's leader - acting Leader of the loyal(?) Opposition. Yippee!
Economic Disaster One Averted. Economic Disaster Two Unfolds.
There are two types of economists at work today. There's the A Team, guys like Krugman and Stiglitz. There's the B Team, guys like Harper and the people advising American politicians. The A Team win Nobel Prizes. They foresaw the great American meltdown, what Robert Reich calls the Great Recession, and warned everybody and anybody who would listen that it was coming. Then there's the B Team economists, those who, well after the fact, said no one could have seen the Great Recession coming and the same gang who, today, say the answer to America's (and other countries' economic woes) lies in Draconian spending cuts.
The powerful didn't listen to the A Team last time and it cost their country dearly. That enabled their financial institutions to go on a crazy bender, all in the name of Casino Capitalism. It started a trend that continues to rock the world today and is far from over. The powerful didn't heed the A Team warnings that they were heading for trouble and, now, they're ignoring the A Team warnings about making those troubles infinitely worse.
The B Team, the pompous halfwits who didn't see this mess coming, say the way ahead now demands massive cuts in government spending. And that's going to mean finding money in working class entitlements such as Medicare and Social Security in order to preserve upper class entitlements also known as the Bush Tax Cuts for the Rich. Curiously enough, a lot of working class Americans who drape themselves in flags and march to the fife and drum think this is a good thing but I did say they're curious.
As Economic Disaster One has been averted, temporarily, it paves the way for Economic Disaster Two to unfold. The Campaign for America's Future has identified four ways the spending cuts will impact blue and white collar Americans.
1. You'll be less likely to find a job if you're looking. If you've got a job, you're less likely to earn more money - and more likely to lose it.
2. Your housing value is likely to suffer.
3. Your old age just got scarier.
4. Your tax bill is likely to go way up.
What Congress has created isn't really an austerity programme at all. It's a "disparity" programme, one that simultaneously enshrines federal largesse for the super rich and deepens the already cavernous inequality gap between rich and poor. They may try to pitch it as a temporary, emergency measure but the cuts to Social Security, Medicare and other working class benefits will be every bit as permanent as the tax windfall they've handed the rich.
And what have they achieved with their Capitol Hill perfidy? Will their "slash and burn" austerity programme save America? According to the A Team, the Republicans have launched a very dangerous, potentially lethal policy that will undermine the existing, weak recovery and could actually trigger a full scale Depression. If Krugman, Stiglitz and Reich are correct, yet again, Congress is about to break working class America on the wheel. But then again, this wasn't really about austerity and fiscal conservatism. This was about concluding the greatest transfer of wealth and power in history from ordinary Americans, its former middle class, to the richest of the rich. And the Tea Partiers cheered on.
The powerful didn't listen to the A Team last time and it cost their country dearly. That enabled their financial institutions to go on a crazy bender, all in the name of Casino Capitalism. It started a trend that continues to rock the world today and is far from over. The powerful didn't heed the A Team warnings that they were heading for trouble and, now, they're ignoring the A Team warnings about making those troubles infinitely worse.
The B Team, the pompous halfwits who didn't see this mess coming, say the way ahead now demands massive cuts in government spending. And that's going to mean finding money in working class entitlements such as Medicare and Social Security in order to preserve upper class entitlements also known as the Bush Tax Cuts for the Rich. Curiously enough, a lot of working class Americans who drape themselves in flags and march to the fife and drum think this is a good thing but I did say they're curious.
As Economic Disaster One has been averted, temporarily, it paves the way for Economic Disaster Two to unfold. The Campaign for America's Future has identified four ways the spending cuts will impact blue and white collar Americans.
1. You'll be less likely to find a job if you're looking. If you've got a job, you're less likely to earn more money - and more likely to lose it.
2. Your housing value is likely to suffer.
3. Your old age just got scarier.
4. Your tax bill is likely to go way up.
What Congress has created isn't really an austerity programme at all. It's a "disparity" programme, one that simultaneously enshrines federal largesse for the super rich and deepens the already cavernous inequality gap between rich and poor. They may try to pitch it as a temporary, emergency measure but the cuts to Social Security, Medicare and other working class benefits will be every bit as permanent as the tax windfall they've handed the rich.
And what have they achieved with their Capitol Hill perfidy? Will their "slash and burn" austerity programme save America? According to the A Team, the Republicans have launched a very dangerous, potentially lethal policy that will undermine the existing, weak recovery and could actually trigger a full scale Depression. If Krugman, Stiglitz and Reich are correct, yet again, Congress is about to break working class America on the wheel. But then again, this wasn't really about austerity and fiscal conservatism. This was about concluding the greatest transfer of wealth and power in history from ordinary Americans, its former middle class, to the richest of the rich. And the Tea Partiers cheered on.
Monday, August 01, 2011
The New York Times - "A Terrible Deal"
Today's New York Times editorial isn't pulling any punches about Obama's debt ceiling deal, calling it precisely what it is - a capitulation.
...The deal would avert a catastrophic government default, immediately and probably through the end of 2012. The rest of it is a nearly complete capitulation to the hostage-taking demands of Republican extremists. It will hurt programs for the middle class and poor, and hinder an economic recovery.
...in the end, most Democrats will have no choice but to swallow their fury, accept the deal and, we hope, fight harder the next time.
The paper laments that the few principles for which the Dems held out were, for the sake of a deal, abandoned.
Democratic negotiators ...are counting on future Congresses to undo its arbitrary butchering.
Sadly, in a political environment laced with lunacy, that calculation is probably correct. Some Republicans in the House were inviting a default, hoping that an economic earthquake would shake Washington and the Obama administration beyond recognition. Democrats were right to fear the effects of a default and the impact of a new recession on all Americans.
President Obama could have been more adamant in dealing with Republicans, perhaps threatening to use constitutional powers to ignore the debt ceiling if Congress abrogated its responsibility to raise it. But this episode demonstrates the effectiveness of extortion. Reasonable people are forced to give in to those willing to endanger the national interest.
I think Obama has all but sealed his fate in 2012. He was elected by a narrow margin thanks to an overwhelming surge of support from progressives who embraced his message of hope and change. He made too many promises that, with rare exception, he has ignored or betrayed. It's going to be very hard, possibly at this stage impossible, for Obama to mobilize those supporters again.
...The deal would avert a catastrophic government default, immediately and probably through the end of 2012. The rest of it is a nearly complete capitulation to the hostage-taking demands of Republican extremists. It will hurt programs for the middle class and poor, and hinder an economic recovery.
...in the end, most Democrats will have no choice but to swallow their fury, accept the deal and, we hope, fight harder the next time.
The paper laments that the few principles for which the Dems held out were, for the sake of a deal, abandoned.
Democratic negotiators ...are counting on future Congresses to undo its arbitrary butchering.
Sadly, in a political environment laced with lunacy, that calculation is probably correct. Some Republicans in the House were inviting a default, hoping that an economic earthquake would shake Washington and the Obama administration beyond recognition. Democrats were right to fear the effects of a default and the impact of a new recession on all Americans.
President Obama could have been more adamant in dealing with Republicans, perhaps threatening to use constitutional powers to ignore the debt ceiling if Congress abrogated its responsibility to raise it. But this episode demonstrates the effectiveness of extortion. Reasonable people are forced to give in to those willing to endanger the national interest.
I think Obama has all but sealed his fate in 2012. He was elected by a narrow margin thanks to an overwhelming surge of support from progressives who embraced his message of hope and change. He made too many promises that, with rare exception, he has ignored or betrayed. It's going to be very hard, possibly at this stage impossible, for Obama to mobilize those supporters again.
The Wisdom of the Great - George Orwell
"In a time of deceit telling the truth is a revolutionary act."
"Political language is designed to make lies sound truthful and murder respectable, and to give an appearance of solidity to pure wind. "
"The most effective way to destroy people is to deny and obliterate their own understanding of their history."
"If you want a picture of the future, imagine a boot stamping on a human face—for ever."
"If liberty means anything at all, it means the right to tell people what they do not want to hear."
"Big Brother is Watching You."
"But if thought corrupts language, language can also corrupt thought."
"Until they became conscious they will never rebel, and until after they have rebelled they cannot become conscious."
"To see what is in front of one’s nose needs a constant struggle."
"All the war-propaganda, all the screaming and lies and hatred, comes invariably from people who are not fighting."
"Orthodoxy means not thinking--not needing to think. Orthodoxy is unconsciousness."
"Every war when it comes, or before it comes, is represented not as a war but as an act of self-defense against a homicidal maniac."
"We are all capable of believing things which we know to be untrue, and then, when we are finally proved wrong, impudently twisting the facts so as to show that we were right."
"Journalism is printing what someone else does not want printed: everything else is public relations."
"The propagandist's purpose is to make one set of people forget that certain other sets of people are human."
Freedom is the right to tell people what they do not want to hear."
"Everyone believes in the atrocities of the enemy and disbelieves in those of his own side, without ever bothering to examine the evidence."
"In real life it is always the anvil that breaks the hammer..."
"Progress is not an illusion; it happens, but it is slow and invariably disappointing."
"If people cannot write well, they cannot think well, and if they cannot think well, others will do their thinking for them."
"If both the past and the external world exist only in the mind, and if the mind itself is controllable - what then?"
"Power is not a means; it is an end."
"It is curious how people take it for granted that they have a right to preach at you and pray over you as soon as your income falls below a certain level."
"Advertising is the rattling of a stick inside a swill bucket. "
"...the object of waging a war is always to be in a better position in which to wage another war."
"As I write, highly civilized human beings are flying overhead, trying to kill me."
"The nationalist not only does not disapprove of atrocities committed by his own side, but he has a remarkable capacity for not even hearing about them."
"At a time of universal deceit telling the truth is considered a revolutionary act."
"Great spirits have always encountered violent opposition from mediocre minds."
"Within any important issue, there are always aspects no one wishes to discuss."
"It was like swimming against a current that swept you backwards however hard you struggled, and then suddenly deciding to turn round and go with the current instead of opposing it. Nothing had changed except your own attitude: the predestined thing happened in any case."
"Sometimes the first duty of intelligent men is the restatement of the obvious."
"You must try harder. It is not easy to become sane."
"If you can feel that staying human is worth while, even when it can't have any result whatever, you've beaten them."
"The aim of the joke is not to degrade the human being, but to remind him that he is already degraded."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

