Monday, September 18, 2017

Monbiot on the Malignancy of Growth

It's encouraging to see more voices speaking out against the heresy of modern politics - perpetual, exponential growth. There are those, our prime minister among them, who cling to the notion of constant increase in GDP as a measure of success. These people are fools no matter how many of them rise to the top tiers of power in parliaments or board rooms. Fools, all of them, and we pay a high price for indulging them.

George Monbiot sees today's hyper capitalism at the root of our failure to address crises such as climate change. 

A system that depends on growth can survive only if we progressively lose our ability to make reasoned decisions. After our needs, then strong desires, then faint desires have been met, we must keep buying goods and services we neither need nor want, induced by marketing to abandon our discriminating faculties, and to succumb instead to impulse.

You can now buy a selfie toaster, that burns an image of your own face on to your bread – the Turin Shroud of toast. You can buy beer for dogs and wine for cats; a toilet roll holder that sends a message to your phone when the paper is running out; a $30 branded brick; a hairbrush that informs you whether or not you are brushing your hair correctly. Panasonic intends to produce a mobile fridge that, in response to a voice command, will deliver beers to your chair.

Urge, splurge, purge: we are sucked into a cycle of compulsion followed by consumption, followed by the periodic detoxing of ourselves or our homes, like Romans making themselves sick after eating, so that we can cram more in.

Continued economic growth depends on continued disposal: unless we rapidly junk the goods we buy, it fails. The growth economy and the throwaway society cannot be separated. Environmental destruction is not a byproduct of this system: it is a necessary element.

The environmental crisis is an inevitable result not just of neoliberalism – the most extreme variety of capitalism – but of capitalism itself. Even the social democratic (Keynesian) kind depends on perpetual growth on a finite planet: a formula for eventual collapse. But the peculiar contribution of neoliberalism is to deny that action is necessary: to insist that the system, like Greenspan’s financial markets, is inherently self-regulating. The myth of the self-regulating market accelerates the destruction of the self-regulating Earth.

Monbiot takes up the call for a new system that includes a new ethics, a new politics and a new economic paradigm. People like Trudeau and the leaders of our other mainstream parties stand in the way with their feet of clay. The longer we tolerate them the worse our chances of being overtaken by events they will not even address.


Toby said...

All of our holidays have been turned into demands to buy, buy, buy. Christmas, Easter, Mothers Day, Fathers Day, birthdays, Halloween, etc. have become horrors of consumption. Consumerism has ruined what should be good days with family and friends.

Lorne said...

I read the article yesterday, and the kind of brainwashing Toby alludes to will, of course, help lead us to our downfall. The values of community and friendship seem to mean little if not 'proven' with gifts and other largesse.

The Mound of Sound said...

As I mentioned earlier, Lorne, I'm fast losing faith in our society. In so many ways we seem to have become infantilized. We grumble yet we don't speak out. We tolerate what we should resist. It's no wonder those who ought to fear us as a society instead see us as pushovers readily distracted, divided, confused and enfeebled. We are their doormats.

Makes me want to pull up stakes, cash out and build that little cabin on some isolated lake up island.

Hugh said...

It seems blatantly obvious: of course you can't have infinite growth on a finite planet.

Both our BC provincial and federal governments are blabbing about having 'clean growth': nonsense.

That mobile beer fridge sounds kind of cool. Not that I really need one.

Trailblazer said...

Maybe it all started when we used perfectly good fresh bread for toast!
Used to be that we used old dry bread for that purpose.
Toilet paper, na, use the National Post instead.

Jokes aside; when we waste the little things the big things don't seem so bad anymore.

Costco shopping for one!
All you can eat restaurants!

The list is endless.


Owen Gray said...

The more we consume, the higher the mountain of garbage we leave behind.

Toby said...

The Mound of Sound said, "Makes me want to pull up stakes, cash out and build that little cabin on some isolated lake up island."

Shades of the 1960's. Just remember that guy who wanted to avoid WWII and moved himself and family to Guadalcanal. Then there is that BC family which wanted to get away from it all and moved to the Falkland Islands just a few weeks before the Argentines attacked. Sometimes history comes knocking no matter what you do. Still, I long to move back up north for similar reasons.